Monday, January 13, 2014

First Semester Reflection


            This semester of blogging showed me many of the challenges that came along with viewing the world through an ethical lens, but it also yielded many of the rewards. My choice of blog topic was different from most of my classmates, many of whom chose long-held interests or topics of previous experience. Ethics is not a long-held fascination of mine, but rather a side-interest that I felt this project would allow me to explore.
            My process for each blog piece was standard. First, I determined a topic to write about. Whenever possible, I picked out situations from my own life, but most of my topics came in the form of news articles. After choosing a subject, I identified the ethical angles involved and did a pro/con analysis. This was harder to do when I had my own clear stance on the issue. For example, on the Pillars of Islam post, I had to ethically justify censorship of an educational Islam poster which I strongly believed had every right to exist. Finally, for each scenario I had to figure out what the purpose of examining the situation was in the first place and ended the post on that note.
            Although many of my posts were on news articles, my favorite ones were the situations pulled from my own experiences. Each case was something I had struggled with personally which made them much more fulfilling to talk about than any of the news articles. For example, my post about the Canned Food Drive was extremely personal and allowed me to examine my own choices from an ethical standpoint. It became my favorite because it helped me realize that the compromise I came to over which types of food to buy for the drive was the most ethical solution, and resolved any conflict I felt over having to make such a decision.  Although on a more micro-scale than mall bombings or affirmative action policies, these posts felt more important to me personally.
            Although I was always interested about the topics I wrote about, ethics as a lens in general has turned out to be a challenging theme to blog about for me. I am a straightforward person who likes clear-cut answers and viable results, and I discovered early on that my exploration of ethics was not going to yield either of these things. The nature of ethics is a struggle between right and wrong, and in none of the scenarios I discussed was I able to determine which was which. Every dilemma had valid arguments from every perspective: even the parents who protested the display of an educational Islam poster were ethically justified in not wanting their children exposed to religion in schools. Every post I made started with an ethical dilemma and ended as an ethical dilemma because no clear solution was ever possible. This was frustrating because part of me felt like the work I was doing was fruitless. What was the purpose of examining these scenarios if I couldn't determine the right thing to do in the end? However, I eventually came to understand the value of examining problems without black-and-white solution. I stopped searching for the absolute rights and wrongs and started to question what ethical stances should be prioritized. This shift had a very meaningful impact on my analytical thought process.
            Beyond my own experience with blogging, I also have a great appreciation for the blogs that my classmates have created over this semester. My favorite blog to read has been Jack’s blog about devils advocacy. My favorite post of his was the one he wrote about the use of offensive language in rap music. I resonated strongly with his point that rappers may be “trying to be offensive, making it all the more appropriate. The number one priority is for a speaker to make their message clear and intended. Considering the array of meanings these words have accumulated in 21st century conversation, and their expressive, colorful nature, there should be no reason why we can't accept their places in our vernacular”. Before reading his post, I had resolutely disagreed with the use of such language in music because it seemed crude and unnecessary; his post completely changed my mindset and allowed me to see the complex choices that some rappers were making in being so purposely offensive. His posts consistently challenged my own viewpoints, which is not an easy thing to do and gave me a great respect for his blog.
            Overall, this experience has been very beneficial and I look forward to continuing to examine the world and my own life through this lens next semester. 

Word Count: 748

1 comment:

  1. Thanks for the shout out Katy! I really appreciate your kind words on my blog, and I'm very glad I've been able to make a significant impression on a reader through the topics I choose to discuss. I have to say I've become a fan of your blog myself. This might be in due in part to the fact that I actually see a fair amount of similarities between our blogs; we both tend to analyze the gray areas of modern dilemmas. Your focus obviously comes more from an ethical perspective, whereas I attempt more to give credence to unpopular opinions, but we both deal with some abstract questions. Instead of looking at what is right or wrong, it's important sometimes just to consider if something is more right or less wrong than its counterpart, while still not perfect itself.

    I look forward to reading more of your blog as well, who knows, maybe we'll end up collaborating down the road. The fact that you've taken the time to read and comment on my blogs really makes it a much more worthwhile process for me, and I'm very grateful. I talked about community participation in my blog reflection, and how I truly believe the more we invest ourselves in these blogs, the more significant and enriching they'll become. Thanks for fueling the process so far, and I hope we can continue to do the same.

    ReplyDelete